Click Here

 
You are Here: Home > Position-by-position report card for the two competing Grey Cup teams
Position-by-position report card for the two competing Grey Cup teams
By Dan Ralph, THE CANADIAN PRESS
Nov 28, 2009 - 5:56:20 PM

Email this article
Printer friendly page

CALGARY - The CFL's top two teams will meet Sunday in the Grey Cup game.

The Montreal Alouettes were first in the East Division after compiling a league-best 15-3 record, while Saskatchewan finished atop the West Division for the first time since 1976 with a 10-7-1 mark.

Montreal advanced to its seventh Grey Cup appearance since 2000 with a 56-18 win over the B.C. Lions in the East Division final. The Roughriders are in their second CFL title game in three years after a 27-17 win over Calgary in the West Division final.

Here's a position-by-position grade for both teams heading into the big game:

Montreal Alouettes

Quarterback: Anthony Calvillo, a 16-year veteran, is appearing in his seventh Grey Cup game. He was named the CFL's outstanding player for the second straight year and third time in his career after leading the CFL with 26 touchdown passes against just six interceptions. Backup Adrian McPherson is very solid.

Grade: A-plus

Receiver: A solid crew here, with Kerry Watkins (81 catches, 1,243 yards, eight TDs), Jamel Richardson (85 catches, 1,055 yards, nine TDs) and Ben Cahoon (89 catches, 1,031 yards, two TDs). Brian Bratton (58 catches, 613 yards, two TDs) is also a dependable performer.

Grade: A.

Running back: Avon Cobourne is a big-play contributor. He rushed for 1,214 yards (5.4-yard average) and 13 TDs and added 56 catches for 458 yards and two TDs. If Cobourne goes down, backup Brandon Whitaker (26 carries, 151 yards, 5.8-yard average per carry) is more than capable.

Grade: A

Offensive line: There's a reason why Montreal's offence is so potent. Plain and simple, Calvillo has time to pass and Cobourne has holes to run through. Guard Scott Flory was named the CFL's top lineman for the second straight year. He anchors a solid front wall. But the Alouettes gave up 35 sacks and both Flory and centre Bryan Chiu are well into their 30s.

Grade: B-plus

Defensive line: This unit featured one of the CFL's sack leaders in John Bowman (12) and the East Division's top defensive player nominee, Anwar Stewart. The Alouettes were second in the CFL in sacks (42), but first in 21 of the league's 25 defensive categories. Enough said.

Grade: A.

Linebackers: Chip Cox stepped up from the secondary and made an immediate impact, posting a team-high 81 tackles. Sophomore Shea Emery has a bright future while veteran Diamond Ferri is under-rated.

Grade: B-plus.

Secondary: First-year CFL defensive backs Billy Parker and Jerald Brown have fit nicely into this unit. Canadian Davis Sanchez and Mark Estelle are both experienced and there's a good 1-2 punch at safety with Etienne Boulay and Matthieu Proulx.

Grade: B

Special Teams: Kicker Damon Duval scored a CFL-record 242 points and posted a 44.8-yard punting average. Returner Larry Taylor was the CFL's top special-teams player. But Montreal had some issues covering kicks.

Grade: A-minus.

Coach: Marc Trestman followed up a solid rookie campaign with an even better sophomore season, leading Montreal to a team-record 15 wins. He's regarded as an offensive guru, and it's no coincidence that Calvillo's excelled the last two seasons. Very cerebral head coach.

Grade: A-plus.

Saskatchewan Roughriders

Quarterback: Darian Durant showed consistent improvement in his first full season as the club's starter. Durant was fourth overall in passing with 4,348 yards and completed over 60 per cent of his throws. Durant is also a threat to run, rushing for 501 yards and a sparkling 8.3 yards per attempt. He had 24 TD passes but also 21 interceptions, the most by a CFL starter. He's made 23 regular-season starts and just one in the playoffs.

Grade: B-plus.

Running back: The Roughriders were the only CFL team not to have a 1,000-yard rusher this season. Wes Cates finished the season with 932 yards rushing and a solid 4.8 yards per carry despite missing two games while recovering from off-season shoulder surgery. The club has some depth with Hugh Charles and Johnny Quinn.

Grade: B.

Offensive line: The unit is anchored by tackle Gene Makowsky and centre Jeremy O'Day, both CFL all-stars this year. Chris Best and Marc Parenteau have both been solid at guard, as has first-year tackle Joel Bell. Stability is a key element as this will mark the 12th consecutive game Saskatchewan has gone with the same starting five up front. The Riders gave up 41 sacks, sixth-most in the league.

Grade: B.

Receivers: Weston Dressler led the way with 62 catches and 941 yards despite suffering a season-ending broken leg and sprained ankle in a win over Toronto. Canadians Andy Fantuz (67 catches, 882 yards, four TDs), Rob Bagg (59 catches, 807 yards, five TDs) and Chris Getzlaf (41 catches, 531 yards, six TDs) have more than picked up the slack.

Grade: B-plus.

Defensive line: Two solid ends here with Stevie Baggs and John Chick. Baggs finished tied for the CFL sacks title with 12, while Chick added 11 and was named the league's top defensive player. Keith Shologan and Marcus Adams are the tackles, with Shologan filling the big shoes created by the retirement of nine-year stalwart Scott Schultz.

Grade: A.

Linebackers: A solid unit here, led by middle linebacker Rey Williams, who made 10 tackles and three sacks in the division final against Calgary. Sean Lucas had a team-high 81 tackles while Tad Kornegay has shown flashes of brilliance.

Grade: A.

Secondary: Cornerback Omarr Morgan makes the first Grey Cup appearance of his 10-year CFL career. Halfback Eddie Davis, playing for the third championship of his stellar 15-year career, has still got it. Lance Frazier led the team with five interceptions.

Grade: B-plus.

Special Teams: Kick-returner Jason Armstead has been a nice addition with his knack for giving the Riders solid field position. He opened the second half of the West Division final with a key 75-yard kickoff return. Kicker Luca Congi is reliable (33-of-43 field goals, 76.7 per cent) while rookie Louie Sakoda replaces injured veteran Jamie Boreham on punts and kickoffs.

Grade: B.

Coach: The Riders raised eyebrows two years ago when they promoted Ken Miller to replace the departed Kent Austin. But all Miller has done is win, compiling a 22-13-1 record in guiding Saskatchewan to consecutive playoff berths. Miller's laid-back demeanour and even-keel approach to the game have made him a popular figure with his players and fans alike. A class act.

Grade: A-minus.


Copyright 2007 - MOP Squad Sports

Top of Page